I met A when they were just a wee child, about 12-years-old. Their uncles were my friends, and although they're like 20 years younger than me, I have always considered them a friend as well. They celebrate their birthday this week so Jeremy and I decided to take them to NYC for an overnight trip. It was brutally cold the entire time we were in the city, so A took us to a pie shop they used to frequent when they lived in NYC. Apparently they came here to treat themselves after midterms and other victories over stress. The shop was empty almost the entire time we were there, which was okay with us because there are only two tiny tables and we took over the entire corner. The rest of the seating is a bar, facing out the front window, which is much too tall for a person in a wheelchair to use. Coffee and hot chocolate both got the thumbs up. This is a bigger achievement than you might realize because Jeremy is Hella picky about Coffee. The triple Berry pie is just the right amount of tart. Key lime is good too. The Mississippi mud pie was a bit of a struggle because it was so rich - terrible problem to have, right? But that's okay, we took the rest back to the hotel and ate it later that night. The staff was lovely and the shop was spotlessly clean. We had a great time.

My favorite pie place hands down..also love the carrot and chocolate cakes. Staff always friendly and helpful. They've renovated and made the spot bigger.Comfortable to dine inside or out. Arnold the owner is a star and always kind even when passing by in the neighborhood. 10 stars from me...

Extremely delicious pies! Really loved the crust on the chicken pot pie - very buttery and good!

They used to have a LOT more goodies for half-price after 7pm . But I today I was lucky to get their banana cream pie, totally worth it! Made fresh and delicious. I paid $6 instead of $12 ... probably could splint w/ a friend but sooo good ... my server give me a hint on taking the pie to go home without spilling it! .

On a recent visit to see Hell's Kitchen we were lucky enough to visit Little Pie Company. The shop is warm and welcoming. It smelled so delicious. Service was wonderful. The pies were absolutely yummy! We had the following: chicken pot pie, peach pie, key lime pie, apple pie and mixed berry. My favorite was the key lime pie. The crust and filling were so delicious.

This pretty little shop is on 43rd between 9th and 10th, more towards 9th. The Little Pie Company is a cute shop, bright and clean, aesthetically pleasing. There is outsideThat serves hot and cold beverages, coffees & teas but the best part is the array of little pies & cakes, for the times you have a small craving and big pies and cakes for when the craving is big! They serve apple turnovers, brownies, cookies, and cupcakes. They also offer a gluten-free Blueberry Apple Crumb and a Florida Key Lime Pie. All pies are made from scratch. I specifically came in, hoping for a croissant. Disappointed when there was none but only briefly when they offered the giant, flaky apple turnover. This turnover was stuffed with nicely cooked sweet & tart apple filling. The flaky crust is tender and flaky. It was croissant adjacent. There is a small covered outside seating area. The service was amazing. Even advised that if I can't get back home for a visit, they ship.

Best pies in the city!!!! My husband and I used to walk by this shop every day when we worked in the city and when you pass the shop the smell is intoxicating! Now Every time my husband heads into the city for work he gets me something from here and I am never disappointed! Their sour cream apple walnut pie is delicious and the flavor profile is elevated so much compared to a regular apple pie. The crumblies on top are delicious! I have also had some of their cookies and they have always been delicious.

This place did not disappoint! The Mississippi Mud Pie was phenomenal! This is a chocolate on chocolate on chocolate pie that's delicious. Each bite is decadent and chocolatey. The textures are soft and tender, with the exception of the chocolate cookie crust. There are so many flavors offered, I'd definitely try others. I can't wait to explore the other offerings. They ship nationwide as well, so it's easy to enjoy this dessert even if you're not in the city.

Super cute little bakery with a nice selection of mini pies for grab and go. This place has been on my list for awhile so I'm glad I was finally able to stop by. It was so hard to choose just one but my all time favorite is a banana pie so of course that's what I got. This particular banana pie also has coconut which was extremely complimentary. The service was quick and friendly. Everything about the pie was delicious from the coconut flakes to the buttery crust. It was also loaded with banana which I absolutely appreciated. Highly recommend this spot and cannot wait to return to try some other flavors!

I finished an amazing dinner nearby before a show at the Westside Theater which is located right across the street from Little Pie Company. Before the show started, I wanted to get a slice of NY cheesecake and a cup of coffee (sometimes I fall asleep watching a long show, especially in the evening), so this pie store was perfect. The cheesecake was good, and paried with the black coffee, it was exactly what I was looking for. I got to bring my coffee into the theater and I enjoyed the show, watching my celebrity crush Constance Wu, crush the role of Audrey in Little Shop of Horrors!